| 2024-11-23 22:30:0023/11/2024 | New York City | 0 - 2 | NY Red Bulls | MLS Playoffs | N/A |
| 2024-11-09 21:00:0009/11/2024 | FC Cincinnati | 0 (5) - 0 (6) | New York City | MLS Playoffs | N/A |
| 2024-11-02 21:00:0002/11/2024 | New York City | 3 - 1 | FC Cincinnati | MLS Playoffs | N/A |
| 2024-10-28 22:45:0028/10/2024 | FC Cincinnati | 1 - 0 | New York City | MLS Playoffs | N/A |
| 2024-10-19 23:00:0019/10/2024 | Montreal | 2 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-10-06 21:25:0006/10/2024 | New York City | 3 - 1 | Nashville SC | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-10-03 00:30:0003/10/2024 | New York City | 3 - 2 | FC Cincinnati | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-09-29 00:30:0029/09/2024 | NY Red Bulls | 1 - 5 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-09-21 19:00:0021/09/2024 | New York City | 1 - 1 | Inter Miami | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-09-19 00:30:0019/09/2024 | New York City | 1 - 5 | Philadelphia | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-09-15 00:30:0015/09/2024 | DC United | 1 - 1 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-09-01 00:30:0001/09/2024 | Columbus | 4 - 2 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-08-25 00:30:0025/08/2024 | New York City | 2 - 2 | Chicago | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-08-17 23:00:0017/08/2024 | Columbus | 1 (4) - 1 (3) | New York City | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
| 2024-08-14 01:00:0014/08/2024 | Tigres | 1 - 2 | New York City | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
| 2024-08-10 00:30:0010/08/2024 | New England | 1 (6) - 1 (7) | New York City | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
| 2024-08-06 01:00:0006/08/2024 | FC Cincinnati | 4 - 2 | New York City | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
| 2024-07-29 01:00:0029/07/2024 | New York City | 0 - 0 | Queretaro | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
| 2024-07-21 00:30:0021/07/2024 | Orlando | 1 - 1 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-07-18 00:30:0018/07/2024 | Atlanta | 2 - 2 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-07-14 01:30:0014/07/2024 | Chicago | 0 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-07-07 02:56:0007/07/2024 | Austin FC | 2 - 1 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-07-04 00:30:0004/07/2024 | New York City | 2 - 0 | Montreal | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-06-29 00:30:0029/06/2024 | New York City | 4 - 2 | Orlando | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-06-23 01:30:0023/06/2024 | Nashville SC | 1 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-06-20 03:30:0020/06/2024 | LA Galaxy | 2 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-06-15 01:30:0015/06/2024 | New York City | 2 - 3 | Columbus | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-06-01 00:30:0001/06/2024 | New York City | 5 - 1 | San Jose | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-05-26 00:30:0026/05/2024 | New England | 0 - 1 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-05-19 00:30:0019/05/2024 | New York City | 2 - 1 | NY Red Bulls | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-05-16 00:30:0016/05/2024 | Philadelphia | 1 - 2 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-05-12 00:30:0012/05/2024 | Toronto FC | 2 - 3 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-05-05 21:00:0005/05/2024 | New York City | 0 - 2 | Colorado | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-04-28 00:30:0028/04/2024 | New York City | 2 - 1 | Charlotte FC | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-04-21 00:30:0021/04/2024 | New York City | 2 - 0 | DC United | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-04-14 00:30:0014/04/2024 | New York City | 2 - 0 | New England | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-04-07 00:30:0007/04/2024 | New York City | 1 - 1 | Atlanta | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-03-30 23:30:0030/03/2024 | Inter Miami | 1 - 1 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-03-23 23:30:0023/03/2024 | FC Cincinnati | 1 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-03-16 23:30:0016/03/2024 | New York City | 2 - 1 | Toronto FC | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-03-09 19:00:0009/03/2024 | New York City | 1 - 2 | Portland | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-03-03 01:30:0003/03/2024 | St Louis City | 2 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2024-02-25 00:30:0025/02/2024 | Charlotte FC | 1 - 0 | New York City | MLS | N/A |
| 2023-08-31 00:30:0031/08/2023 | New York City | 2 - 0 | Montreal | MLS | N/A |
| 2023-08-04 01:00:0004/08/2023 | NY Red Bulls | 1 - 0 | New York City | MX/US Leagues Cup | N/A |
